Never heard of this one!

As regular readers know, I have a habit of buying up joblots of old fishing tackle and then spending hours of my free time sifting through the detritus looking for bits I can use or salvage. This harmless idiosyncrasy keeps my amused and on the odd occasion turns up little gems of old gear. As I have a few days off work I am shifting through a box of bits which had been waiting for my attention since last year. This particular container was filled with some fly tying materials which I had gone through once previously and rescued some nice capes, but today I was literally scraping the bottom when I cam across a small fly in a clear packet. With it was a handwritten note.

I have never come across a Stooger fly before, in scarlet or any other shade for that matter. I suspect this is a pattern dreamt up by an angler for his or her own use rather than a copy of a recognised dressing (but I could be wrong). This formulating new dressings is an everyday event and we anglers who make their own flies have row upon row of such self designed patterns in their boxes, most of which rarely ever even get wet. That this particular fly warranted the hand written note suggests it was tied up for someone else, perhaps after a good day with the Stoodger. Did someone fill a basket with trout and then pass one of the successful flies on to a fellow fisher? Was it posted on or slipped across the breakfast table in the hotel before the boats went out the next day? I will never know but I admit that finding the note is even more intriguing than the actual fly itself.

So what is this fly? It’s dressed on a round bend size 10 hook with an impressively large barb. That hook looks like a very old Mustad or similar. Tying silk looks like it is black but the black varnish on the head makes that hard to be sure. Tail fibres came from some unidentifiable game bird which was marled and possibly had been dyed red, but it was hard to be more precise than that. Under the body there were wraps of wire, presumably to weight the fly. The body itself consisted of a bright blue hackle which had be wound in touching turns and cut short to give an unusual spiky sort of look to the fly. Two hackles, the first one of ginger cock and the front one of reddish claret completed the fly. Was that front hackle supposed to be scarlet? In my experience, dyed feathers grow paler with age or exposure to the sun so I have my doubts that scarlet feathers were used.

The style of the fly and its inclusion with a box of stuff for making similar patters suggested to me it has been tied for lough fishing, most likely in Scotland. A fly box retrieved earlier from the same haul contained Scottish lough flies such as Malloch’s Favourite, Cinnamon and Gold, Blue Zulu and others I would have used myself back in the land of my birth.

Where the name ‘Stoodger’ comes form is a mystery. I can’t find any reference to fly or indeed, in English dictionaries. Is it just a corruption of ‘Stooge’? Regardless, I have stuck the Scarlet Hackled Stoodger in my fly box and plan to give it a swim next season. Who knows, I might have a killer on my hands!

For the day that is in it, I want to wish everyone reading this post a healthy, happy and safe 2024. While ’23 was a very good year for me personally I know many people had a tough 12 months and I sincerely hope next year is a better one for you.

Published by Claretbumbler

Angler living and fishing in the West of Ireland. Author of 'Angling around Ireland'. Aberdonian by birth, rabid Burnley fc supporter. Have been known to partake of the odd pint of porter.

10 thoughts on “Never heard of this one!

  1. Happy New Year to you Colin, when it comes and good luck with your plans! I’m enjoying the book, thanks. Regarding the Stooger – probably a made up , last chance fly for when nothing else works? Was it you who said previously that most amateur fly tying experiments have probably been tried and not entered the list of popular flies for a reason? That said I, like all of us, long to find that magic fly 😊. My ‘experiments’ are generally simple variants of a common pattern, though perhaps all flies are variants or interpretations of the tier? I read an old book about a guy’s quest to find the ‘ultimate fly’ for hill lochs in Wales, if I remember correctly. He attempted to take a logical approach to this and the process took years. He looked at using one pattern for the whole season and kept meticulous records of catches to compare with previous years ( interestingly he found little difference when using a greenwell’s for the whole season!) Eventually he settled on some simple black spider type thing with a hackle at both ends, I think. Over time I think he returned to a more varied approach. The Stooger looks like something very quirky and unconventional and I can almost hear the banter of it’s creator joking with his fellow anglers. We all enjoy some version of this I think! One last thought – could it have been a sort of false positive fly to trick another angler into believing it was the hot pattern and fishing with it? That probably tells you more about some of the characters I fish with 😂, but would fit the name well.

    Like

Leave a reply to cloudman1130 Cancel reply